Your new girl is beautiful
Looks like she's in love
Made me kinda trip and fall
In memories of us

I call a truce, I wanna be cool
But all that you do, just know that I've been there too
And being your first, is making this worse

You coulda been here dancing with me
Under these lies, my feelings on fire
Still crashing my dreams
Back when I was your girl, I wanna be her now

Oh-aah, oh-aah, oh-aah
Been there too
Aah-oh, aah-oh, aah

Even though we didn't make it
Baby, I'm not mad
I'll just be the second greatest
Love you ever had

And that's the truth, I wanna be cool
But all that you do, just know that I've been there too
And being your first, is making this worse
It hurts

You coulda been here dancing with me
Under these lies, my feelings on fire
Still crashing my dreams
Back when I was your girl, I wanna be her now

Oh-aah, oh-aah, oh-aah
Been there too
Aah-oh, aah-oh, aah
Oh, oh, oh, woah-woah
Oh, oh, oh

You're gonna love her better (and that's not fair)
I was your trial and error (no, that's not fair)
You're gonna love her better (I got you here)
I was your trial and error

You coulda been here dancing with me (yeah, yeah, yeah)
Under these lies, my feelings on fire
Still crashing my dreams
Didn't wanna be first, I wanna be her now (I wanna be her)

Oh-aah, oh-aah, oh-aah
Been there too
Aah-oh, aah-oh, aah