Well I sleep with you
But you dream of him
And pretend every touch of my hand is his
You lead me on
In the same trip
I can tell by your eyes
What you truly feel, oh

I tuck you in
After you drink
I take advantage
Of this opportunity
But I lay awake
Thinking of her
And you just put your hands on me
As you have before

I am yours
And you are mine
Just as we go on pretending tonight
We both know
This is make believe
I don't believe you when you said
I swept you off your feet

We'll both fake it
Pretend we'll make it
Make it as we have
With a past lover [x2]

Close your eyes
And drift fast asleep
As I pleasure you
With my company
My eyes are fake
Because I'm staying awake
How can I sleep dreaming of her with you next to me?

We'll both fake it
Pretend we'll make it
Make it as we have
With a past lover [x2]