Why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya (Uh-huh)
Why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya, good for ya (Uh-huh)

I've been on my best behavior for life
Why you gotta judge me just for one night? (Ah-ah)
Even when I’m reckless, I always do what's right
So give me one more try (Let me off this time)
Let me off this time

Why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya (Uh-huh)
Why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya, good for ya (Uh-huh)
Maybe all my love for you was too nice
So why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya, good for ya (Uh-huh)

I ain't ever been naughty, naughty, no, no
I never been naughty, naughty, no, no
I ain't ever been naughty, naughty, no, no
I never been naughty, naughty, no, no

I got you too heated, you're melting my ice
And I think you forgot to check your list twice
‘Cause I (Ah)
Even when I’m reckless, I always do what’s right
So give me one more try (Let me off this time)
Let me off this time

Why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya (Uh-huh)
Why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya, good for ya (Uh-huh)
Maybe all my love for you was too nice
So why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya, good for ya (Uh-huh)

I ain't ever been naughty, naughty, no, no
I never been naughty, naughty, no, no
I ain't ever been naughty, naughty, no, no
I never been naughty, naughty, no, no

Give me one, one reason for this
'Cause there's two sides to everything
I need three, real apologies
Take me off that list
There’s only been four times you walked out that door
And five different ways that I've cried
And six, I'm so tired of this
That’s my Christmas list

So why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya (Uh-huh)
Why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya, good for ya (Uh-huh)
Oh, maybe all my love for you was too nice
So why you put me on the naughty list? (Uh-huh)
Maybe I was too good for ya, good for ya (Uh-huh)
(I was too good for ya)

I ain't ever been naughty, naughty, no, no
I never been naughty, naughty, no, no
I ain't ever been naughty, naughty, no, no
I never been naughty, naughty, no, no
(I was too good for ya)