I've rejected affection for years and years
Now I have it and, damn it, it's kind of weird
He tells me I'm pretty, don't know how to respond
I tell him that he's pretty too, can I say that? Don't have a clue

With every passing moment, I surprise myself
I'm scared of flies, I'm scared of guys, someone please help
'Cause I think I've fallen in love this time
I blinked and suddenly I had a Valentine (I had a Valentine)

What if he's the last one I'll kiss?
What if he's the only one I'll ever miss?
Maybe I should run, I'm only twenty-one
I don't even know who I want to become

I've lost all control of my heartbeat now
Got caught in a romance with him somehow
I still feel a shock through every bone when I hear an: I love you
'Cause now I've got someone to lose

The first one to ever like me back
I'm seconds away from a heart attack
How the hell did I fall in love this time?
And, honestly, I can't believe I get to call you mine
I blinked and suddenly I had a Valentine (Valentine)