Do you hear the words I mumble?
Do you care if I should stumble?
Do you curse the day I met you?
Because I left you
But I won't forget you

Could it be that I have faltered
I remember why I altered

I left you for another man
And he doesn't deserve me
I know this inside
But he holds my heart
Between light and the dark
And I, I wish it was you
Yes I, I wish it was you
Oh I

When I think of how you held me
Like I was the one and only
I wish that I could love you
Like I ought to
Like I wanted to

I could have stayed in sweeter days
I felt the sun had just begun

But I left you for another man
And he doesn't deserve me
I know this inside
But he Keeps my heart
Between light and the dark
And I, I wish it was you
Yes I, I wish it was you
Oh I